Eastern Caribbean Supreme Court
  • About Us
    • Brief History of the Court
    • Court Overview
    • Meet the Chief Justice
    • Past Chief Justices
      • Sir Hugh Rawlins
      • Sir Brian George Keith Alleyne
      • His Lordship, the Hon. Justice Adrian Saunders
      • Hon. Sir Charles Michael Dennis Byron
      • Rt. Hon. Sir Vincent Floissac
      • Honourable Sir Lascelles Lister Robotham
      • More..
        • Hon. Neville Algernon Berridge
        • Sir Neville Peterkin
        • Sir Maurice Herbert Davis
        • Justice P. Cecil Lewis
        • Sir Allen Montgomery Lewis
    • Judicial Officers
      • Justices of Appeal
        • His Lordship, the Hon. Justice Davidson Kelvin Baptiste
        • His Lordship, the Hon. Justice Mario Michel
        • Her Ladyship, the Hon. Justice Gertel Thom
        • His Lordship, the Hon. Justice Paul Anthony Webster [Ag.]
        • His Lordship, the Hon. Justice Gerard Farara, KC
        • His Lordship, the Hon. Justice Trevor Ward, KC
      • High Court Judges
      • Masters
    • Court of Appeal Registry
    • Court Connected Mediation
      • Court-Connected Mediation Practice Direction Forms
      • Mediation Publications
    • More…
      • Career Opportunities
      • Legal Internship
      • Transcript Requests
      • Directory
  • Judgments
    • Privy Council
    • Caribbean Court of Justice
    • Court Of Appeal Judgments
    • High Court Judgments
    • Digests of Decisions
    • Country
      • Anguilla
      • Antigua & Barbuda
      • Grenada
      • Montserrat
      • Saint Kitts and Nevis
      • Saint lucia
      • Saint Vincent & The Grenadines
      • Territory of the Virgin Islands
    • Year
      • 1972 – 1990
        • 1972
        • 1973
        • 1975
        • 1987
        • 1989
        • 1990
      • 1991 – 2000
        • 1991
        • 1992
        • 1993
        • 1994
        • 1995
        • 1996
        • 1997
        • 1998
        • 1999
        • 2000
      • 2001 – 2010
        • 2001
        • 2002
        • 2003
        • 2004
        • 2005
        • 2006
        • 2007
        • 2008
        • 2009
        • 2010
      • 2011 – 2019
        • 2011
        • 2012
        • 2013
        • 2014
        • 2015
        • 2016
        • 2017
        • 2018
        • 2019
    • Judgment Focus
  • Sittings & Notices
    • Schedule of Sittings
    • Court of Appeal Sittings
    • Chamber Hearing (Appeals)
    • Case Management (Appeals)
    • High Court Sittings
    • Status Hearings
    • Special Sittings
    • Notices
  • Court Procedures & Rules
    • ECSC Court of Appeal Rules
    • ECSC (Sittings of the Court) Rules, 2014
    • Civil Procedure Rules [WEB]
    • ECSC Civil Procedure Rules
      • Civil Procedure Rules 2000 [Amendments to Nov 2015]
      • Civil Procedure (Amendment) Rules 2014
      • ECSC Civil Procedure (Amendment) (No.2) Rules
      • Civil Procedure Rules 2000 [Amendments to May 2014]
      • Civil Procedure (Amendment) Rules 2013
      • Civil Procedure (Amendment) Rules 2011
    • ECSC Criminal Procedure Rules
      • Criminal Procedure Rules SI No. 22 of 2015
    • ECSC Sentencing Guidelines
    • Non Contentious Probate Rules and Administration of Estates
    • Family Proceedings Rules
    • More..
      • Election Petition Rules
      • Legal Profession Disciplinary Procedure Rules (St. Lucia)
      • Code Of Judicial Conduct
      • Court Forms
        • Introduction of E-Filing
        • BVI Commercial Division E-Filing
        • Court-Connected Mediation Practice Direction Forms
      • Court Proceedings Fees
      • SILK Application Procedure
      • Practice Directions
      • Practice Notes
      • Video Conferencing Protocols
  • News & Publications
    • ECSC Media Gallery
    • Annual Reports
    • Appointments
    • Press Releases
    • Papers & Presentation
      • Opening of the Law Year Addresses
    • Tributes
  • E-Litigation
    • E-Litigation Portal
    • E-Litigation Instructional Videos
    • ECSC E-Litigation Portal User Information
    • Electronic Litigation Filing and Service Procedure Rules
    • Notices of Commencement
    • E-Litigation Publications
  • J.E.I
    • JEI History
    • Structure of JEI
    • JEI Chairman
    • Mandate, Objectives, Standards
    • Programmes Archive
      • Conferences
      • Programmes & Projects
      • Symposiums
      • Training
      • Workshops
    • Upcoming Activities
more
    • About Us
    • Meet the Chief Justice
    • Civil Procedure Rules
    • Mediation
    • Careers
  • Contact
  • Saved for Later
 Home  E-Litigation Portal
  •  Court Procedures And Rules
    • Civil Procedure Rules
    • Court Forms
    • Election Petition Rules
    • Practice Directions
  •  Judgments
    •  All
    •  Court of Appeal
    •  High Court
    •  Digest of Decisions
  •  Sittings
    •  All
    •  Court of Appeal
    •  High Court
  • Sign In
    
    Minimize Search Window
    •       {{item.title}} Filter By Category {{SelectedFilters.length}}x Categories 
    •       {{item.title}} {{selectedCountries.length}}x Countries Country 
    •       {{item.title}} Filter By Year {{selectedOptions.length}}x Options 
    
    Sorry can't find what you're looking for try adjusting your search terms
    Appeal
    {{doc._source.post_title}}
    Page {{indexVM.page}} of {{indexVM.pageCount}}
    pdf
    Home » Digests of Decisions » Court of Appeal Sitting – 3rd May 2022

    EASTERN CARIBBEAN SUPREME COURT

    COURT OF APPEAL

    STATUS HEARING

     

     

    TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS

    VIDEOCONFERENCE

    Tuesday, 3rd May 2022

     

       
      STATUS HEARINGS
       
       
    Case Name: Claude Skelton-Cline
    v
    Cabinet of the Virgin Islands
     
     
    [BVIHCVAP2019/0003]
     
       
    Date: Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Coram: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:  
     Appellant:Ms. Malika George
       
     Respondent:Ms. Maya M. Barry
       
       
    Issues: Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Order: Adjournment
       
    Result / Order:  [Oral Delivery]
     
    IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
     
    The matter is adjourned to the next Status Hearing of the court for the Territory of the Virgin Islands scheduled for 26th September 2022, to allow the appellant to continue to make the necessary arrangements for the payment of the transcript of proceedings.
       
       
    Reason: The appellant indicated that he has been unable to acquire finances to pay for the transcript of proceedings and requested more time to do so. The respondent did not object to the request.
       
       
       
    Case Name: Bernadette McKelly
    v
    The Registrar of Lands
     
    [BVIHCVAP2020/0007]
       
    Date: Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Coram: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:  
     Appellant:In person
       
     Respondent:No appearance
       
       
    Issues: Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Order: Directions
       
       
    Result / Order: [Oral Delivery]
     
    IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
    1.    The appellant shall make the necessary arrangements for the payment of the transcript of proceedings in a timely manner.
    2.    The matter shall thereafter proceed in accordance with the Civil Procedure Rules 2000.
    3.    The Registrar of the High Court shall serve a copy of this order on the respondent and shall provide proof of service thereafter.
     
       
       
    Reason: The transcript of proceedings has been prepared, however, due to financial challenges, the appellant requested additional time to acquire the funds to pay.
       
       
    Case Name: John Forster Emmott
    v
    Michael Wilson & Partners Ltd.
    [BVIHCMAP2017/0002]
     
    Michael Wilson & Partners Ltd.
    v
    John Forster Emmott
    [BVIHCMAP2017/0003]
     
    Kazholdings Incorporated
    Kazholdings LLP et al
    v
    [1] John Forster Emmott
    [2] Michael Wilson & Partners Ltd.
    [BVIHCMAP2017/0005]
       
    Date: Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Coram: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:  
     Appellants:Mr. John Forster Emmott in person
    Mr. Michael Wilson in person
    Ms. Laura Gunn for Kazholdings Incorporated and Kazholdings Incorporated LLP
       
     Respondents:Mr. John Forster Emmott in person
    Mr. Michael Wilson in person
       
       
    Issues: Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Order: Directions
       
       
    Result / Order: IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
    1.    The Registrar of the High Court shall provide the appellant, John Forster Emmott with the necessary banking information on or before 6th May 2022, to allow for payment of the transcript of proceedings.
    2.    The appellant, John Forster Emmott shall make the necessary arrangements for the payment of the transcript of proceedings in a timely manner after the banking information has been provided by the Registrar of the High Court.
    3.    The matter shall thereafter proceed in accordance with the Civil Procedure Rules 2000.
     
       
       
    Reason: The transcript of proceedings has been prepared and  Mr. John Forster Emmott indicated that he would be in a position to pay the costs of the transcript once he receives the necessary banking information from the Court.  Directions were therefore necessary to further the matter.
       
       
       
    Case Name: Charmaine Rosan-Bunbury
    v
    The Attorney General
     
    [BVIHCVAP2015/0017]
       
    Date: Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Coram: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:  
     Appellant:Mr. David Penn
       
     Respondent:Ms. Maya M. Barry
       
       
    Issues: Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Order: Adjournment
       
       
    Result / Order: [Oral Delivery]
     
    IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
     
    The matter is adjourned to the next Status Hearing of the Court for the Territory of the Virgin Islands scheduled for 26th September 2022 to allow the parties to take the necessary steps to continue efforts to reconstruct the file in this matter.
       
       
    Reason: The matter was adjourned as the case file was destroyed in Hurricane Irma in September 2017 and the parties require additional time to reconstruct the file.
       
       
       
    Case Name: Rasshain Lavacia
    v
    International Motors Limited
     
    [BVIHCVAP2015/0013]
       
    Date: Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Coram: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:  
     Appellant:No appearance
       
     Respondent:Mr. Dave Marshall
       
       
    Issues: Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Order: N/A
       
    Result / Order: N/A
       
       
    Reason: The Court noted that a notice of appeal has never been filed in this matter therefore, the jurisdiction of the Court had not been engaged. Accordingly, no order can be made in this matter.
       
       
       
    Case Name: McArthur Engineering Company Limited
    v
    [1] Christian Cottoy
    [2] Annita Cottoy
     
    [BVIHCVAP2016/0001]
       
    Date: Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Coram: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:  
     Appellant:Mr. Monroe Penn in person
       
     Respondents:No appearance
       
       
    Issues: Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Order: Adjournment
       
    Result / Order: [Oral Delivery]
     
    IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
    1.    The matter is adjourned to the next Status Hearing of the Court for the Territory of the Virgin Islands scheduled for 26th September 2022 to allow the appellant to provide the court with a filed copy of the notice of appeal in this matter.
    2.    The Registrar of the High Court shall serve a copy of this order on the appellant and shall provide proof of service thereafter.
       
       
    Reason: The Court noted that although leave to appeal was granted by this Court in February 2016, it is unclear whether the notice of appeal was in fact filed by the appellant’s former counsel, accordingly the appellant requested additional time to settle the matter and to retain new counsel.
       
       
    Case Name: Chagala Group Ltd
    v
    TIPP Investments PCC
     
    [BVIHCMAP2018/0017]
       
    Date: Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Coram: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:  
     Appellant:No appearance
       
     Respondent:No appearance
       
       
    Issues: Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Order: N/A
       
    Result / Order: IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
     
    The matter is removed from the Status Hearing List and will be placed before the Full Court.
       
       
    Reason: The parties expressed in writing their intention to dispose of the appeal.
       
       
       
    Case Name: Emmerson International Corporation
    v
    Renova Industries Ltd
     
    [BVIHCMAP2019/0018]
       
    Date: Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Before: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:  
     Appellant:No appearance
       
     Respondent:No appearance
       
       
    Issues: Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Oral Result / Order Delivered: N/A
       
    Result / Order: IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
     
    This matter be removed from the Status Hearing List.
       
       
    Reason: This matter was listed in error as it has already been heard before the full court.
       
       
       
    Case Name: [1] Sylvia Maduro-Dale
    [2] Lucia Chalwell
    v
    The Registrar of Lands
     
    [BVIHCVAP2010/0022]
       
    Date: Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Coram: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:  
     Appellants:No appearance
       
     Respondent:Ms. Maya M. Barry
       
       
    Issues: Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Order: Adjournment
       
    Result / Order: [Oral Delivery]
     
    IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
    1.    The matter is adjourned to the next Status Hearing of the Court for the Territory of the Virgin Islands scheduled for 26th September 2022 to allow the appellants to indicate whether they are still interested in prosecuting this appeal.
    2.    The Registrar of the High Court shall serve a copy of this order on the appellants and shall provide proof of service thereafter.
     
       
       
    Reason: The Court noted that the appellants were not with the notice of status hearing and on the last occasion, their counsel’s application to be removed from the record was granted.
       
       
       
    Case Name:  The Queen
    v
    [1]Yan Edwards
    [2] Allen Baptiste
     
    [BVIHCRAP2020/0002]
       
    Date:  Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Coram: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:   
     Appellant: Ms. Kellee-Gai Smith
       
     Respondents: Mr. Sherfield Bowen for Mr. Edwards
    Mr. Israel Bruce for Mr. Baptiste
       
    Issues:  Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Order: N/A
       
       
    Result / Order:  [Oral Delivery]
     
    IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
     
    The hearing of the appeal is fixed for the next sitting of the Court of Appeal in the Territory of the Virgin Islands scheduled for the week commencing 3rd October 2022.
       
       
    Reason:  Submissions have been filed by all parties and the matter is ready to proceed.
       
       
       
    Case Name:  Antonio Stoutt
    v
    The Commissioner of Police
     
    [BVIMCRAP2015/0006]
       
    Date:  Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Coram: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:  
     Appellant:Mr. Stephen Daniels appearing amicus curiae
       
     Respondent: Mrs. Tiffany Scatliffe-Esprit, Director of Public Prosecutions
       
       
    Issues:  Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Order: Adjournment
       
       
    Result / Order:  [Oral Delivery]
     
    IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
     
    1.    Counsel Mr. Stephen Daniels shall take the necessary steps to enter a notice of acting for the appellant on or before 13th May 2022.
    2.    The matter is adjourned to the next Status Hearing of the Court for the Territory of the Virgin Islands scheduled for 26th September 2022. 
     
       
       
    Reason:  Mr. Daniels indicated that he had only recently been approached by the appellant and has yet to file a notice of acting. He also informed that he required time to peruse the record to decide whether the notice of appeal needs to be amended.
       
       
       
    Case Name:  Jaime Scatliffe
    v
    The Commissioner of Police
     
    [BVIMCRAP2020/0008]
    [BVIMCRAP2020/0009]
    [BVIMCRAP2020/0010]
       
    Date:  Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Coram: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:  
     Appellant:Mr. Michael Maduro
       
     Respondent: Ms. Kellee-Gai Smith
       
       
    Issues:  Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Order: Adjournment
       
       
    Result / Order:  [Oral Delivery]
     
    IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
     
    The matter is adjourned to the next Status Hearing of the Court for the Territory of the Virgin Islands scheduled for 26th September 2022 to allow counsel for the appellant to regularise his legal representation of the appellant and to be fully instructed.
       
       
    Reason:  The appellant required additional time to properly retain and instruct counsel.
       
       
       
    Case Name:  Delvin Green
    v
    The Commissioner of Police
     
    [BVIMCRAP2020/0002]
    [BVIMCRAP2020/0009]
       
    Date:  Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Coram: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:  
     Appellant:Mr. Michael Maduro holding for Ms. Valerie Gordon
       
     Respondent: Mrs. Tiffany Scatliffe-Esprit, Director of Public Prosecutions
       
       
    Issues:  Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Order: Adjournment
       
       
    Result / Order:  [Oral Delivery]
     
    IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
    1.    The Senior Magistrate shall cause a supplemental record of appeal to be filed to include the reasons for decision on or before 29th July 2022, failing which the Magistrate shall provide an affidavit giving reasons for the non-compliance.
    2.    The matter is adjourned to the next Status Hearing of the Court for the Territory of the Virgin Islands scheduled for 26th September 2022.
       
       
    Reason:  The record of appeal does not contain the reasons for decision from the magistrate, therefore additional time was required to rectify this issue.
       
       
       
    Case Name:  Ricardo Leonard
    v
    The Commissioner of Police
     
      [BVIMCRAP2020/0003]    
    [BVIMCRAP2020/0004]
    [BVIMCRAP2020/0005]
       
    Date:  Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Coram: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:  
     Appellant:Mr. Stephen Daniels appearing amicus curiae
       
     Respondent: Mrs. Tiffany Scatliffe-Esprit, Director of Public Prosecutions
       
       
    Issues:  Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Order: Adjournment
       
       
    Result / Order:  [Oral Delivery]
     
    IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
     
    The matter is adjourned to the next Status Hearing of the Court for the Territory of the Virgin Islands scheduled for 26th September 2022 to allow the appellant to provide proof of service of the notice of appeal on the respondent.
       
       
    Reason:  The respondent informed the Court that it had not been served with the notice of appeal.
       
       
       
    Case Name:  Brian Penn
    v
    The Commissioner of Police
    [BVIMCRAP2018/0003]
       
    Date:  Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Coram: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:  
     Appellant:In person
       
     Respondent: Mrs. Tiffany Scatliffe-Esprit, Director of Public Prosecutions 
       
       
    Issues:  Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Order: Adjournment
       
       
    Result / Order:  [Oral Delivery]
     
    IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
    1.    The matter is adjourned to the next Status Hearing of the Court for the Territory of the Virgin Islands scheduled for 26th September 2022 to allow the appellant to provide proof of service of the notice of appeal on the respondent.
    2.    The Registrar of the High Court shall serve a copy of this order on the appellant and shall provide proof of service thereafter.
     
       
       
    Reason:  The respondent informed the Court that it had not been served with the notice of appeal. The appellant indicated that he would require some time to ascertain whether the matter  contact his former counsel who prepared the notice of appeal.
       
       
       
    Case Name:  Sayied Scatliffe
    v
          Smith Seaman                                
     
    [BVIMCVAP2016/0002]
       
    Date:  Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Coram: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:  
     Appellant:Mr. Michael Maduro appearing amicus curiae
       
     Respondent: Ms. Malika George
       
       
    Issues:  Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Order: Adjournment
       
       
    Result / Order:  [Oral Delivery]
     
    IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
    1.    The matter is adjourned to the next Status Hearing of the Court for the Territory of the Virgin Islands scheduled for 26th September 2022 for the appellant to indicate whether he is still interested in prosecuting this appeal.
    2.    The Registrar of the High Court shall serve a copy of this order on the appellant and shall provide proof of service thereafter.
     
       
       
    Reason:  Counsel for the appellant was not certain whether the appeal is still viable and will take instructions from the appellant to determine whether he remains interested in prosecuting the appeal.
       
       
    Case Name:  Kelly Ann Percival
    v
    Alimha Beresford
     
    [BVIMCVAP2019/0001]
       
    Date:  Tuesday, 3rd May 2022
       
    Coram: Mrs. Michelle John-Theobalds, Chief Registrar
       
    Appearances:  
     Appellant:Mr. Michael Maduro
       
     Respondent: No appearance
       
       
    Issues:  Status of the matter
       
       
    Type of Order: Adjournment
       
       
    Result / Order:  [Oral Delivery]
     
    IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
     
    The matter is adjourned to the next Status Hearing of the Court for the Territory of the Virgin Islands scheduled for 26th September 2022 to allow the parties to continue settlement discussions.
       
       
    Reason:  The parties requested additional time to continue engaging in settlement discussions.  
       
       

     

    https://www.eccourts.org/court-of-appeal-sitting-3rd-may-2022/
     Prev
    Maureen Dyett v Mary Casarin
    Next 
    Denise Tuitt v Rosanna Tuitt
    Eastern Caribbean Supreme Court

    2nd Floor Heraldine Rock Building
    Waterfront
    P.O. Box 1093
    Castries
    Saint Lucia
    T: +1 758 457 3600
    E: offices@eccourts.org

    • About Us
      • Court Overview
      • Career Opportunities
      • Directory
      • Privacy Policy
    • Judgments
      • Court Of Appeal
      • High Court
    • Sittings
      • Chamber Hearing
      • Court of Appeal
      • High Court
    • News & Updates
      • Appointments
      • Press Releases
    • Civil Procedure Rules
      • Court Forms
      • Practice Directions
    © 2023 Eastern Caribbean Supreme Court. All Rights Reserved

    Submit your email address and name to subscribe for email notifcations.

    [email-subscribers-advanced-form id="1"]
    Bookmark
    Remove Item
    Sign in to continue
    or

    Bookmarked Items
    •  Home
    • Judgments
    • Sittings
    •  News
    •  more