IN THE COURT OF APPEAL 

MONTSERRAT

CIVIL APPEAL NO. c1 of 1973

ALLEN ROWLAND DUTCHER 

AND 

JOHN MACKINNON 

Before  The Honorable the Chief Justice 

The Honorable Mr. Justice St. Bernard 

The Honorable Mr. Justice Peterkin 

J. Kelsick for appellant.

K. Allen for respondent.

1975 July 21 & 25

JUDGMENT

Peterkin J.A.