JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF December 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
HMB Holdngs Ltd v The Attorney General et al
HCVAP 2010/007
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 05/12/11

ST KITTS & NEVIS
Cedric Liburd v Eugene Hamilton et al
HCVAP 2010/017, 2010/018
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 05/12/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Cukurova Finance International Ltd et al v Alfa Telecom Turkey Ltd
HCVAP 2010/018, 2010/024
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 05/12/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
The Queen v Everton Welch
Criminal Case No ANUHCR 1994/0015
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 14/12/11

The Queen v Avie Howell et al
Criminal Case No ANUHCR 2010/0029-0030
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 16/12/11

Christiana Yearwood v Robin Yearwood
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0362
Michel, J.
Delivered: 08/12/11

Noreen Francis v Titus Francis
Claim No ANUHMT 2002/0044
Michel, J.
Delivered: 14/12/11

Kate Morris v Alphaeus Anthony et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0587
Michel, J.
Delivered: 20/12/11

Lilouti Gooroodat v Imtiazul Tallim
Claim No ANUHMT 2011/0093
Michel, J.
Delivered: 21/12/11

Gary Nelson v The Attorney General et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/00552
Remy, J.
Delivered: 13/12/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Marcus Romain v Joy Adrien
DOMHCV2009/0041
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 07/12/11

The State v Jachelena Lewis
DOMHCR 2011/029
Stephenson-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 05/12/11

SAINT LUCIA
General Investments Ltd et al v Joan Marquis
Claim No SLUHCV 2009/0398
Belle, J.
Delivered: 12/12/11

Bernard Prospere et al v Anthea Lynch et al and Margaret Lynch v Bernard Prospere et al
SLUHCV 2007/0619, 2008/1223
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 02/12/11

Morella Vitalis v Paul St Rose et al
SLUHCV 2006/0991
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 09/12/11

Gregor Juilan et al v Winfresh Ltd
SLUHCV 2010/0756
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 15/12/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Calvin Todman v Marguerite Hodge
Claim No BVIHCV 2009/0020
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 29/12/11

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF November 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
The Liquidators of Eurofed Bank Ltd v The Supervisory Authority
HCVAP 2010/051
Rawlins, C.J.
Delivered: 21/11/11

GRENADA
Anthea de Bellotte v The Minister of Communications Works et al
HCVAP 2011/017
Mitchell, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 22/11/11

Janin Caribbean Construction Ltd v Ernest Wilkinson
HCVAP 2010/001
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 07/11/11

Joan Isaac v Cecil Isaac
HCVAP 2009/013
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 21/11/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Kent Andrews et al v The Attorney General
HCVAP 2010/019
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 07/11/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Deshawn Stoutt v The Queen
HCRAP 2009/003
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 07/11/11

Melvina Frett-Henry v Tortola Concrete Ltd et al
HCVAP 2008/024
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 21/11/11

Jeremy Outen John Milsom and David Standish v Mukhtar Ablayazov
HCVAP 2011/030
Judgment of the Court
Delivered: 10/11/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Robert Josiah v State Insurance Corporation
Claim No. ANUHCV 2010/0474
Michel, J.
Delivered: 07/11/11

Amos Charles v Tessa Charles
Claim No. ANUHCV 2008/0677
Michel, J.
Delivered: 15/11/11

R Allen Stanford v The Liquidators of Stanford International Bank Ltd
Claim No. ANUHCV 2009/0149
Michel, J.
Delivered: 15/11/11

La Tanya Hughes v Clement Hughes
Claim No. ANUHCV 2010/0455
Remy, J.
Delivered: 03/11/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Jeffery Charles v Lovette Charles
DOMHCV 2003/032
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 29/11/11

Cecilia Robin v The Attorney General et al
Claim No DOMHCV 2011/0060
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 16/11/11

SAINT LUCIA
Vernon James et al v Minivelle & Chastanet Ltd et al
SLUHCV 2010/1072
Belle, J.
Delivered: 15/11/11

Angus Wayne Vitalis v Florentius St Marie
Claim No SLUHCV 2010/0239
Belle, J.
Delivered: 17/11/11

Regina v Gaius McLauren
Criminal Case No SLUCRD 2011/0079
Cumberbatch, J.
Delivered: 15/11/11

Regina v Clive McVane
Criminal Case No SLUHCRD 2010/0215
Cumberbatch, J.
Delivered: 30/11/11

Bank of St Lucia Ltd v Shery Heinis et al
SLUHCV 2004/0876
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 11/11/11

Treasure Bay (St Lucia) Ltd v The Gaming Authority et al
Claim No SLUHCV 2011/0456
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 07/11/11

Ausbert Regis, Commissioner of Police v The Attorney General of Saint Lucia
Claim No SLUHCV 2010/0497
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 21/11/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Linton Lewis v Colin Williams et al; Nigel Stephenson v Colin Williams et al; Vynette Frederick v Colin Williams et al; Patricia Chance v Colin Williams; Vynette Frederick v Sonya Young
High Court Civil Claim Nos. 19 of 2011, 20 of 2011, 21 of 2011, 76 of 2011, 100 of 2011, 115 of 2011
Thom, J.
Delivered: 15/11/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Liao Chen Toh v Liao Hwang Hsiang
BVIHPB 93 of 2011
Joseph Olivetti, J.
Delivered: 29/11/11

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF October 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Antigua Power Co Ltd v The Attorney General et al
HCVAP 2009/006
Gordon, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 19/10/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Nicholls Esprit et al v Speaker of the House of Assembly et al
HCVAP 2008/005
Gordon, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 19/10/11

ST KITTS & NEVIS
Carleen Pemberton v Mark Brantley
HCVAP 2011/009
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 14/10/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
eChinaCash Inc. v Light Year Partners LLC and another
HCVAP 2010/032
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 19/10/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Troy Lewis v Constable Glendon Samuel et al
Claim No DOMHCV 2010/0068
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 17/10/11

Omarra Small v Michael Laudat et al
Claim No DOMHCV 2010/0012
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 17/10/11

SAINT LUCIA
The Queen v David Poleon et al
SLUHCR 2008/0060
Belle, J.
Delivered: 05/10/11

Hotel Chocolat Estates Ltd v Dasheen (1988) Ltd
SLUHCV 2009/1028
Belle, J.
Delivered: 20/10/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Daphne Alves v The Attorney General
Claim No. BVIHCV 2007/0306
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 24/10/11

The Queen v Calvin Rabsatt
Claim No. BVIHCR 2011/0034
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 24/10/11

JIPFA Investments Ltd v The Ministry of Physical Planning et al
Claim No. BVIHCV 2011/0040
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 31/10/11

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF September 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANGUILLA
A, B, C & D v E
HCVAP 2011/001
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 19/09/11

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Steadroy Benjamin v The Commissioner of Police et al
HCVAP 2009/023
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 19/09/11

GRENADA
Michael McIntyre et al v Grace Steele
HCVAP 2011/002
Mitchell, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 19/09/11

SAINT LUCIA
White Construction Co. Ltd. v DCG Properties Ltd
HCVAP 2010/022
Rawlins, C.J.
Delivered: 26/09/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Chiverton Construction Ltd et al v Scrub Island Development Group Ltd
HCVAP 2009/028
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 19/09/11

Yukos CIS Investments Ltd et al v Yukos Hydrocarbons Investments Ltd et al
HCVAP 2010/028
Redhead, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 26/09/11

Betteto Frett v Flagship Properties Limited
HCVAP 2009/026
[Judgment of the Court]
Delivered: 27/09/11

David Swain v The Queen
HCRAP 2009/008
[Judgment of the Court]
Delivered: 29/09/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Dean Jonas v James Rose
Claim No. ANUHCV 2010/0434
Marthurn, M.
Delivered: 21/09/11

Martin Roopnarine v Andrew Michelin
Claim No. ANUHCV 2009/0135
Michel, J.
Delivered: 19/09/11

Osbert Browne v Joycelyn Browne
Claim No. ANUHMT 2010/0128
Michel, J.
Delivered: 23/09/11

Eliza Paul v Donald Davis et al
Claim No. ANUHCV 2009/0432
Michel, J.
Delivered: 29/09/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Mcpherson Barber v Meyona Samuel
DOMHCV 2009/0101
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 12/09/11

Levie Maximea v Cpl. Nicholas Gordon et al
DOMHCV 2009/0054
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 12/09/11

The Development and Planning Corporation v Gifford Irish
DOMHCV 2009/0399
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 12/09/11

Roy Andrew v Susan Heitz et al
DOMHCV 2009/0410
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 15/09/11

Joseph Leblanc v James Cyrille
DOMHCV 2005/0089
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 15/09/11

Daniel Marie-Sante et al v Trans National Engineering Consultant Inc. et al
DOMHCV 2009/0438
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 15/09/11

Maria Yard v Paul Charles
Claim No DOMHCV 2002/0417
Stephenson-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 30/09/11

GRENADA
Peter Gernert et al v Egmont Development Inc. et al
Claim No GDAHCV 2010/0218
Henry, J.
Delivered: 30/09/11

Joel Horsford v The Attorney General of Grenada
Claim No GDAHCV 2009/0423
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 22/09/11

Kishola Levine v Kenny Smart et al
Claim No GDAHCV 2007/0296
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 22/09/11

Grenada Technical and Allied Workers Union v Hon. Karl Hood
Claim No GDAHCV 2010/0370
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 22/09/11

SAINT LUCIA
Patrick Smith v Willy Vasson et al
SLUHCV 2008/0026
Belle, J.
Delivered: 28/09/11

Garnat George et al v Claudius Etienne
SLUHCV 2007/0698
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 01/09/11

Josephat Small v PC 711 Lester Byron et al
SLUHCV 2007/0866
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 05/09/11

Marcia Polius v The Attorney General
SLUHCV 2009/0178
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 05/09/11

Bryan Felix v The Attorney General et al
SLUHCV 2005/0941
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 21/09/11

Sonia Johnny v The Cabinet et al
Claim No SLUHCV 2010/0931
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 26/09/11

Norma Louisien v Matthew Louisien
Claim No SLUHMT 2010/0008
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 29/09/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Olin Dennie v Cecil McKie et al
Claim No SVGHCV 2010/0206
Actie, M. [Ag]
Delivered: 30/09/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Elisabeth Robertson v Christina Washburn et al
Claim No. BVIHCV 2011/0158
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 23/09/11

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF August 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

GRENADA
Cromwell Scott & Co Ltd v The Appeal Commissioners
GDAHCV 2010/0108
Rawlins, C.J.
Delivered: 24/08/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Quorum Island (BVI) Ltd v Virgin Islands Environmental Council
BVIHCV 2009/021
Rawlins, C.J.
Delivered: 12/08/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Ian Peters v Robert Spencer et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0445
Michel, J.
Delivered: 24/08/11

Ottis Payne et al v Zenroy Athill et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0506
Michel, J.
Delivered: 31/08/11

GRENADA
The Attorney General of Grenada v Seaview Corporation Ltd et al
Claim No GDAHCV 2009/0229
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 29/08/11

SAINT LUCIA
Suzanna Isidore v Norton Gaspard et al
SLUHCV 1996/0400
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 12/08/11

Raoul Odlum v Catherina Jean Jacques et al
SLUHCV 2007/0015
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 12/08/11

Bay View Proprietors v Phillipe Chalano et al
SLUHCV 2009/0592
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 12/08/11

Christine Samuel v Bernard Serieux et al
SLUHCV 2008/0859
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 15/08/11

Alicia Francois v Moses Joseph et al
SLUHCV 2004/0611
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 15/08/11

Sabina Alcide v Marguerite Desir
SLUHCV 2007/0486
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 22/08/11

Sonia Hippolyte v Cletus Hippolyte
SLUHCV 2004/0078
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 22/08/11

Jessica Myers v David Myers
Claim No. SLUHMT 2009/0160
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 25/08/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Adina Garnes et al v Beatrice Gumbs and John Gumbs
High Court Civil Claim Nos 52 of 2009 & 53 of 2009
Thom, J.
Delivered: 10/08/11

Alan Straker v Marcia Stephens
High Court Civil Claim No 130 of 2008
Thom, J.
Delivered: 15/08/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
The Queen v Camillus Paris
Claim No. BVIHCR2010/0014
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 29/08/11

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF July 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
American International Bank Ltd v Landmark Ltd et al
HCVAP 2010/003
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 04/07/11

SAINT LUCIA
Carlos Augustin v Uni-V (St. Lucia) Ltd
HCVAP 2010/044
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 27/07/11

Elias George v The Queen
HCVAP 2009/026
Rawlins, C.J. [Judgment of the Court]
Delivered: 25/07/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Alfa Telecom Turkey Ltd v Cukurova Finance International Ltd. Et al
HCVAP 2010/018, 2010/024
Gordon, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 20/07/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Sonia Grant v Maynard Williams
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0346
Remy, J.
Delivered: 20/07/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA

Layou Improvement Committee et al v Development and Planning Corporation
DOMHCV 2010/0127
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 06/07/11

Martha LeBlanc v Augustus Thomas et al
DOMHCV 2009/0296
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 06/07/11

Violetta Richards v James Richards
Suit No. DOMHMT 2007/0020
Stephenson Brooks, J.
Delivered: 29/07/11

GRENADA
Patrick Thomas et al v Thomas Real Estate Co Ltd. et al and Patrick Thomas et al v Crochu Beach Resorts Ltd et al
Claim Nos. GDAHCV 2001/0652 & 2001/0653
Henry, J.
Delivered: 01/07/11

James Bristol v Andre Bernard
Claim No. GDAHCV 2009/0499
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 07/07/11

The Minister of Communications, Works et al v Anthea De Bellotte
Claim No. GDAHCV 2010/0310
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 07/07/11

George Donald Barclay et al v Hilda Clement
Claim No. GDAHCV 2003/0177
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 13/07/11

Ann Blackman v Kenny Forrester
Claim No. GDAHCV 2005/0469
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 13/07/11

MONTSERRAT
Lester Greenaway v David Taylor
Claim No. MNIHCV 2009/0007
Redhead, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 26/07/11

Nigel Lindsey v James Allen
Claim No. MNIHCV 2009/0021
Redhead, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 26/07/11

SAINT LUCIA
First Caribbean International Bank (Barbados) Ltd v Eugene Nelson et al
Claim No. SLUHCV 2007/0197
Belle, J.
Delivered: 14/07/11

Godfrey Aurelien v Johny Chitolie
Claim No. SLUHCV 2008/0946
Belle, J.
Delivered: 21/07/11

The Queen v Aldrick William
Claim No. SLUCRD 2009/1690
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 05/07/11

The Queen v Claudius Edward
Case No. SLUHCRD 2009/0025
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 11/07/11

The Queen v Andrew Richardson
Claim No. SLUCRD 2009/0122
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 13/07/11

The Queen v Marlon Charles
Claim No. SLUHCRD 2007/1340
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 29/07/11

The Queen v Lenzie Polemis
Criminal Case No. SLUCRD 2008/1147
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 29/07/11

Albert Augustin v WPC 152 Bertie Ferdinand
Claim No. SLUHCV 2008/0647
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 26/07/11

SAINT VINCENT
Ulric Charles et al v Kristy Antoine et al
High Court Civil Claim No 37 of 2010
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 14/07/11

Fletcher Goodluck v The Superintendent of Prisons et al
High Court Civil Claim No 125 of 2011
Thom, J.
Delivered: 20/07/11

The Incorporated Trustees of the Seventh Day Adventist Church v Delores Jordan
High Court Claim No 48 of 2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 21/07/11

Irma Ollivierre v The Vessel "Bequia Express 1" et al
Claim No 472 of 2010
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 26/07/11

Jacqueline Chance v Jane Sutherland et al
High Court Civil Claim No 90 of 2008
Thom, J.
Delivered: 28/07/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Anju Dhar et al v Glenford David et al
Claim No. BVIHCV2009/0384
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 19/07/11

Eileen Papone et al v James Anthony
Claim No. BVIHCV2010/0113
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 28/07/11

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF June 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

SAINT LUCIA
Anthony John v Antoine Monero
HCVAP 2009/026
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 21/06/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Elwardo Lynch v Ralph Gonsalves and BDS Ltd v Ralph Gonsalves
HCVAP 2009/002, 004
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 21/06/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Commercial Bank - Cameroun v Nixon Financial Group Limited
HCVAP 2011/005
Bennett, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 06/06/11

Jerry Martin v The Queen
HCRAP 2010/014
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 06/06/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA

Anton Tonge v The Attorney General et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2011/0167
Michel, J.
Delivered: 10/06/11

Steve Joseph v Leona Cornelius et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0045
Michel, J.
Delivered: 14/06/11

The Attorney General of Antigua and Barbuda v Antigua Aggregates Ltd et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2005/0492
Michel, J.
Delivered: 17/06/11

Arvo's Ltd v Mark Anthony
Claim No ANUHCV 2011/0336
Michel, J.
Delivered: 20/06/11

In the Estate of Enrico Julian, Deceased
Claim No ANUHPB 2010/0123
Michel, J.
Delivered: 24/06/11

Garfield Christian v Ivan Hixon
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0083
Remy, J.
Delivered: 14/06/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA

Marcus James v Richard Royer
DOMHCV 2006/0098
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 30/06/11

Edison James et al v Speaker of the House of Assembly et al
Claim Nos. DOMHCV 2010/199 & 2010/200
Stephenson-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 10/06/11

Ronald Green v Petter Saint Jean et al and Maynard Joseph v Roosevelt Skerrit et al
Claim Nos. DOMHCV 006 of 2010 & 7 of 2010
Thom, J.
Delivered: 07/06/11

MONTSERRAT
Lilian Riley v Christopher Gerald et al
Claim No. MNIHCV 2004/0009
Leigertwood-Octave, J.
Delivered: 23/06/11

SAINT LUCIA
Ereen Archibald v Attorney General
High Court Civil Claim No 39 of 2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 16/07/11

Dawn Chance v James Chance
High Court Civil Claim No 91 of 2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 16/07/11

Rembert Thomas v Quarry Products Ltd
Claim No. SLUHCV 2009/1693
Belle, J.
Delivered: 15/06/11

The Queen v Kevin Johnny
Criminal Case No. SLUCRD 2009/1268
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 20/06/11

The Queen v Sydney Prescod et al
Criminal Case Nos. SLUCRD 2002/1907, 1908
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 28/06/11

The Queen v Sydney Prescod et al
Criminal Case Nos. SLUCRD 2002/1907, 1908
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 29/06/11

Marie Clarke-Johney v Evariste Ambrose
SLUHCV 2008/0438
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 10/06/11

Victor Delices v Lindley Lubin et al
SLUHCV 2007/0431
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 27/06/11

Antonia Martial v The Public Service Board of Appeal
Claim No SLUHCV 2010/0450
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 22/06/11

SAINT VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

Ereen Archibald v Attorney General
High Court Civil Claim No 39 of 2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 16/07/11

Dawn Chance v James Chance
High Court Civil Claim No 91 of 2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 16/07/11

Christopher McMaster v Attorney General et al
Claim No SVGHCV 2009/00326
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 03/06/11

Gertrude Sewell v Ronald Providence et al
Claim No SVGHCV 2005/0215
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 03/06/11

Sharon Sprott v Corporal 599 Foster Scott et al
Claim No 377 of 2006
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 03/06/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
OBM Ltd v LSJ LLC
Claim No. BVIHCV2009/0451
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 03/06/11

JIPFA Investments Ltd v Natalie Brewley et al
Claim No. BVIHCV2011/0038
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 08/06/11

Mary Williams v The Attorney General
Claim No. BVIHCV2010/0048
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 22/06/11

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF MAY 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ST KITTS & NEVIS
Kemba Swanston v Director of Public Prosecutions
HCRAP 2006/021
Edwards J.A.
Delivered: 17/05/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANGUILLA
Aubrey Smith v Calvert Fleming et al
Claim No AXAHCV 0050/2008
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 27/05/11

Cora Richardson Hodge et al v. Attorney General of Anguilla et al
Claim No AXAHCV 0007/2010
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 27/05/11

Lois Dunbar v Paul Webster
Claim No AXAHCV 0062/2009
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 27/05/11

ANTIGUA
Paget Davis v Ruthlidge Crump et al
Claim No. ANUHCV 2009/0598
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 06/05/11

Janet Cochrane v Volmer Cochrane
Claim No. ANUHCV 2008/0480
Michel, J.
Delivered: 13/05/11

Estlyn Prophet v Royal Antiguan Beach Resorts Ltd
Claim No. ANUHCV 2008/0425
Michel, J.
Delivered: 16/05/11

George Purcell v George W Bennett Brysons & Co Ltd
Claim No. ANUHCV 2006/0631
Michel, J.
Delivered: 20/05/11

Terrance Sansom v Colin Turner
Claim No. ANUHCV 2010/0189
Michel, J.
Delivered: 25/05/11

Terrance Sansom v Colin Turner
Claim No. ANUHCV 2010/0189
Michel, J.
Delivered: 31/05/11

Maurice Joseph v Attorney General
Claim No. ANUHCV 2009/0547
Remy, J.
Delivered: 04/05/11

First Caribbean International Bank (Barbados Ltd v Oriel Walter
Claim No. ANUHCV 2008/0386
Remy, J.
Delivered: 11/05/11

Manuela Morganti v Silkincrest Investment Ltd et al
Claim No. ANUHCV 2009/0195
Remy, J.
Delivered: 17/05/11

Devon Brown v Neil Williams
Claim No. ANUHCV 2009/0636
Remy, J.
Delivered: 30/05/11


COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA

Edison Lewis v Davina Dangleben et al
DOMHCV 2004/0347
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 04/05/11

Anthony Commodore v Michael David
DOMHCV 2010/0241
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 04/05/11

GRENADA
First Caribbean International Bank (Barbados) Ltd
Claim No. GDAHCV 2010/0098
Henry, J.
Delivered: 27/05/11

Donna Neptune-Brathwaite et al v Richardson Pivotte et al
Claim No. GDAHCV 2002/0502
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 04/05/11

Kert Brizan v Director of Public Prosecutions
Claim No. GDAHCV 2010/0551
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 04/05/11

Albert St Bernard v Her Worship Karen Noel et al
Claim No. GDAHCV 2011/0052
Price Findlay, J.
Delivered: 12/05/11

SAINT LUCIA
Cecelia Deterville v Foster & INCE Cruise Services (St Lucia) Ltd
Claim No. SLUHCV 2009/0811
Belle, J.
Delivered: 23/05/11

Denis Mauricette v Eunice Mauricette
Claim No. SLUHMT 2010/0120
Belle, J.
Delivered: 31/05/11

The Queen v Alfredo Rodriguez et al
Claim No. SLUHCRD 2009/1108-1125
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 25/05/11

PC 707 Antoine v Eurious Eugene
Criminal Case No. SLUHCRD 2010/0761
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 27/05/11

CJ's Touring Service Ltd v Saint Lucia Air and sea Ports Authority
SLUHCV 2007/0265
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 05/05/11

First Caribbean International Bank (Barbados) Ltd v Brands Inc (St. Lucia)
Claim Nos. SLUHCV 2007/0640, 2008/0545
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 05/05/11

Charles Bernard et al v Joseph William et al
Claim No. SLUHCV 2006/0397
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 04/05/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

Friendship Bay Hotel Ltd v Braganza AB et al
High Court Civil Suit No 396 of 2010
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 26/05/11

Paul Lewis et al v Canouan Resorts Development Ltd et al
SVGHVC 408 of 2010
Thom, J.
Delivered: 03/05/11

Frank DaSilva et al v Dr the Hon Ralph E Gonsalves et al
High Court Civil Claim No 371 of 2009
Thom, J.
Delivered: 13/05/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Clearlie Todman-Brown v Melvin Rymer
BVIHCV 2010/0049
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 11/05/11

The Queen v Shervon Anthony et al
Criminal Case No 10 of 2010
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 17/05/11

Ian Charles v The Board of Governors of the H Lavity Stoutt Community College
BVIHCV 2010/0049
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 30/05/11

Julian Willock v Attorney General et al
BVIHCV 2010/305A
Joseph-Olivetti, J.
Delivered: 24/05/11

JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF APRIL 2011

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

GRENADA

The Beacon Insurance Co Ltd v Liberty Club Ltd
HCVAP 2010/029
Pereira, J.A.
Delivered: 07/04/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

Ewart Bacchus v The Queen
HCRAP 2008/006
Rawlins, C.J.
Delivered: 29/04/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANGUILLA

The Queen v Gary Fleming
Criminal Case No 0015/2010
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 12/04/11

ANTIGUA

Irma Smith et al v Omari Phillip
Claim No. ANUHCV 2009/0579
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 15/04/11

Govin Singh v Attorney General et al
Claim No. ANUHCV 2008/0268
Michel, J.
Delivered: 20/04/11

Sally Ann Noel v Arthur Noel
Claim No. ANUHMT 1999/0098
Thomas, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 14/04/11

Hazel de Freitas v Attley De Freitas
Claim No. ANUHCV 2008/0476
Thomas, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 14/04/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA

Eslyne Rhyner v Ivan Moreau
DOMHCV 2004/0370
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 06/04/11

Keiron Pinard-Byrne v Comptroller of Inland Revenue
DOMHCV 2006/0292
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 06/04/11

GRENADA
Ashton Coomansingh v Jean Thompson
Claim No GDAHCV 2002/521
Henry, J.
Delivered: 08/04/11

SAINT LUCIA
The Queen v Leo St. Brice
Claim No. SLUCRD 2007/0646 & 647
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 15/04/11

Eudes Borne et al v National development Corporation
Claim No. SLUHCV 2008/0958
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 04/04/11

Patricia Yorkston v Tamarind Village Inc
Claim No. SLUHCV 2009/0465
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 06/04/11

Jennifer Prescott v Aldrick Parris et al
Claim No. SLUHCV 2009/0172
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 07/04/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

Angella Richardson v Wayne Stephens
High Court Civil Suit No 18 of 2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 18/04/11

Thelma Hall et al v Randolph Russell
High Court Civil Suit No 18 of 2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 20/04/11

Wallace Dear v Carlita Cordice et al
Civil Suit No. 93 of 2007
Remy, J.
Delivered: 13/04/11

Millhawke Holdings (Bequia) Ltd et al v Stanley Dormieden et al
High Court Civil Claim No 301 of 2010
Thom, J.
Delivered: 19/04/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLAND

The Queen v Keon Edwards
Criminal Case No 7 of 2009
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 07/04/11

The Queen v Richard Finnegan
BVIHCR 2011/0005
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 14/04/11

The Queen v Vernon Paddy
BVIHCR 2010/0020
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 27/04/11

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

GRENADA

Bank of Nova Scotia v Appeal Commissioners
GDAHCV 2009/0533
Rawlins, C.J.
Delivered: 30/03/11

ST KITTS & NEVIS

Jamoy Warner et al v Director of Public Prosecutions
HCRAP 2009/021/022
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 17/03/11

Vernon S Veira et al v Guy Mitchell et al
HCVAP 2010/021
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 22/03/11

Frantisek Stepanek et al v Aqua Investments Ltd et al
HCRAP 2011/002
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 23/03/11

SAINT LUCIA

Jada Construction Caribbean Limited v The Landing Limited
HCVAP 2009/011
Rawlins, C.J.
Delivered: 08/03/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

Gershon Robertson v Baldwin King
HCVAP 2008/020
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 14/03/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS

Bevern Smith v The DPP
HCRAP 2011/001
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 22/03/11

Westford Special Situations Fund Ltd v Barfield Nominees Ltd et al
HCRAP 2010/014
George-Creque, J.A.
Delivered: 28/03/11

Gerard Kraakman v Donna Sterling
HCRAP 2010/012
Mitchell, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 28/03/11

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA

Selwyn Charles v The Attorney General
Claim No ANUHCV 2011/0069
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 02/03/11

Everette Jonas v Carlton Lewis
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0709
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 29/03/11

Caribbean Developments (Antigua) Ltd v Richard Sayer
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0560
Floyd, J.
Delivered: 30/03/11

Christopher Wheatley et al v Waterpoint Caribbean Homes Ltd
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0029
Remy, J.
Delivered: 09/03/11

Myrtle Looby v Geo Tech Ltd et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0092
Thomas, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 11/03/11

Horizon Construction Ltd v Teddy Santos
Claim No ANUHCV 2005/0553
Thomas, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 25/03/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Kieron Pinard-Byrne v Lennox Linton et al
Claim No DOMHCV 2003/0424
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 22/03/11

ST KITTS & NEVIS

Pina Panchal v Medical University of the Americas Ltd
Claim No. NEVHCV 2003/0096
Leigertwood-Octave, J.
Delivered: 28/03/11

Israel Paul v Julia Thomas et al
Claim No DOMHCV 2005/0221
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 28/03/11

SAINT LUCIA

Marcella de Freitas v Francis Lewis
Claim No SLUHCV 2009/0114
Belle, J.
Delivered: 28/03/11

The Queen v Claudius Joseph
Criminal Case Nos. SLUCRD 2009/0013 & 0014
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 17/03/11

The Queen v Sham Sanganoo
Criminal Case Nos. SLUCRD 2007/0653, 0669 & 0670
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 31/03/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

Friendship Bay Hotel v Branganza AB et al
High Court Civil Claim No 396 of 2010
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 24/03/11

Daniel Cummings v The Central Water and Sewerage Authority
Claim SVGHCV 20009/0124
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 31/03/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLAND

Queen v Andre Penn
BVIHCR2009/0031
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 31/03/11

Mark Bailey v Betty Lou Bailey
Claim No. BVIHMT 2007/0015
Joseph-Olivetti, J.
Delivered: 02/03/11

Lesette Greene v Kenneth Greene
Claim No. BVIHMT 2007/0087
Joseph-Olivetti, J.
Delivered: 10/03/11

Betteto Frett v Owners and other persons interested in ship "Buckpasser Jeanneau 36" et al
Consolidated Claim Nos. BVIHAD2009/0008, 0009, 0010, 0011, 0012, 0015, 0017, 0019, 0023, 0024, 0025
Mitchell, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 25/03/11

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

SAINT LUCIA

SLASPA v Leroy Mathurin et al
HCVAP 2008/035
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 21/02/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Casanki Quow et al v Commissioner of Police
HCRAP 2010/022
Rawlins, C. J.
Delivered: 21/02/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLAND

The Commissioner of Police et al v Rudolph Maduro
HCVAP 2009/016
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 07/02/11

JSC BTA Bank v Fidelity Corporate Services Ltd et al
HCVAP 2010/035
Mitchell, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 21/02/11

HIGH COURT JUUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
DRB Co Ltd et al v Carlton Lewis
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0189
Michel, J.
Delivered: 09/02/11

Montpellier Farm Ltd v Antigua Commercial Bank
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0243
Michel, J.
Delivered: 11/02/11

Josette Michael et al v Robert Benjamin Washington Jr
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0632
Michel, J.
Delivered: 18/02/11

Bobb Persaud v Warren Headley-Hall
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0383
Thomas, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 04/02/11

Everal Green v Attorney General et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0185
Thomas, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 04/02/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
The State v Emmanuel Azille
DOMHCR 2010/00361
Brooks, J.
Delivered: 07/02/11

Bernard Christopher v Roosevelt Skerrit
Claim No DOMHCV 2010/0287
Brooks, J.
Delivered: 18/02/11

Michel Williams v National Bank of Dominica
DOMHCV 2005/0002
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 03/02/11

Webster Shillingford et al v Norma Dalrymple et al
DOMHCV 2008/0308
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 11/02/11

Joseph George v Land Sales, Builders and Financial Ltd
DOMHCV 2007/0163
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 23/02/11

F. Christmas v Natioinal Fair Trade Organisation of Dominica et al
Claim No DOMHCV 2008/4668
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 10/02/11

Joseph Leblanc v Attorney General et al
Claim No DOMHCV 2009/0254
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 10/02/11

Staphine Emanuel v Clyde Lecointe
Claim No DOMHCV 2009/0166
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 10/02/11

Wills Kelsick v Kenny Durand
Claim No DOMHCV 2010/0128
Stephenson-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 18/02/11

Bernard Christopher v Roosevelt Skerrit et al
Claim No DOMHCV 2010/0287
Stephenson-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 18/02/11

GRENADA
Janie Mason v George Mason
Claim No GDAHMT 2009/0004
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 01/02/11

Dorset Mitchell v Keith Gurley
Claim No GDAHCV 2005/0060
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 08/02/11

Kay Simon v Stephen Hardman et al
Claim No GDAHCV 2009/0211
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 15/02/11

SAINT LUCIA

The Queen v Mitchel Joseph
Criminal Case No SLUCR 2008/0818
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 09/02/11

Rosemary Garraway et al v Aloysius Ferdinand
Claim No SLUHCV 2010/0666
Belle, J.
Delivered: 03/02/11

Danny Severin v Attorney General
Claim No SLUHCV 2008/0973
Belle, J.
Delivered: 10/02/11

Barrie Wilkinson v Patricia Devaux
SLUHCV 2008/0637
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 17/02/11

Augustin Montoute et al v Victoire Simon et al
SLUHCV 2006/0905
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 24/02/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Dawn Chance v James Chance
High Court Civil Claim No 91 of 2009
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 02/02/11

Rozemma Shallow v Wesley Mason
High Court Civil Claim No 15 of 2010
Joseph, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 24/02/11

Eric Ollivierre v Wynston Shabazz et al
High Court Civil Claim No 258 of 2009
Thom, J.
Delivered: 11/02/11

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Desmond Alphonso v The Attorney General
Claim No. BVIHCV 2010/0105
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 08/02/10

Andre Penn v The Director of Public Prosecutions
BVIHCR 2009/0031
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 22/02/10

Julian Willock v The Attorney General
Claim No. BVIHCV 2010/305A
Joseph-Olivetti, J.
Delivered: 03/02/10

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

SAINT LUCIA

Earl Hunte v The Queen
HCRAP 2006/012
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 19/01/11

HIGH COURT JUUDGMENTS

ANGUILLA

Hulda Stanley v Lanval Phillips
Claim No AXAHCV 0054/2009
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 13/01/11

Claimants A, B, C and D v Respondent E
Claim No AXAHCV 0063/2010
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 26/01/11

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA

Rosy-Pierre Casimir v Zachary Casimir
Claim No DOMHMT 2009/0011
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 24/01/11

Huron Vidal v Merle Vidal
Claim No DOMHCV 2005/0002
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 25/01/11

Julius Carrierre et al v Jessie Bruney
Claim No DOMHCV 2008/0493
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 25/01/11

GRENADA
Nancy Jaleel v Michael John and Nancy Jaleel v Neville Elcock et al
Claim Nos. GDAHCV 2002/0490 & 2003/0213
Henry, J.
Delivered: 14/01/11

Florence Williams v Grenada Cooperative Bank Ltd
Claim No. GDAHCV 2007/0210
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 18/01/11

SAINT LUCIA

The Queen v Jesse Charles
Criminal Case No. SLUCRD 2009/0008
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 19/01/11

Heirs of Camselle St Catherine v Darius St Catherine et al
Claim No. SLUHCV 2003/0444
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 20/01/11

Andre Alexander v St Lucia Golf Resort & Country Club Ltd
Claim No. SLUHCV 2007/0715
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 25/01/11

Bank of Saint Lucia et al v Madeline Couchman
Claim No. SLUHCV 2010/0389
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 14/01/11

First Caribbean International Bank (Barbados) Ltd v Malcolm Brayshaw
Claim No. SLUHCV 2005/0740
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 31/01/11

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

C. Emmanuel et al v R. Punnett et al and D. Hackshaw et al v O. Samuel et al
High Court Civil Claim No 364 of 2004
Thom, J.
Delivered: 19/01/11

C. Dillon Saul v The Queen
HCRAP 2008/020
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 25/01/11

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA

Carlton Bedminster et al v The Queen
HCRAP 2008/002, 003
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 15/12/10

Roger Naitram et al v The Queen
HCRAP 2006/005, 006, 008
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 15/12/10

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA

Michael Laudat v Danny Ambo
HCVAP 2010/016
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 15/12/10

SAINT LUCIA

Roland Browne v The Public Service Commission
HCVAP 2010/023
Edwards, J.A.
Delivered: 15/12/10

HIGH COURT JUUDGMENTS

ANGUILLA

Thomas P. Lydon et al v Barnes Bay Development Ltd et al
Claim No AXAHCV 0051/2008
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 12/12/10

Sir Emile Gumbs v Sheffield Holdings Ltdl
Claim No AXAHCV 0090/2009
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 13/12/10

Peter Adams v Ermine Adams-Plotkin
Claim No AXAHCV 0034/2009
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 13/12/10

Gwenneth Webster v National Bank of Anguilla Ltd
Claim No AXAHCV 0098/2008
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 22/12/10

Lineth Webster v Carolyn Gumbs
Claim No AXAHCV 0100/2008
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 30/12/10

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA

Gerald Watt v FBO (2000) Antigua Ltd et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0254
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 02/12/10

Malaka Parker v First Caribbean International Bank Ltdl
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0748
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 20/12/10

Sandra George v Clement Samuel et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2004/0293
Michel, J.
Delivered: 13/12/10

Wingrove Jarvis v Mary Jarvis
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0099
Michel, J.
Delivered: 15/12/10

Morris Gardner v Attorney General
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0745
Michel, J.
Delivered: 21/12/10

Joseph Hutchens v Jeffrey Cahall
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0099
Thomas, J.
Delivered: 16/12/10

GRENADA
Catherine Charles v Denham Peters
Claim No GDAHCV 2002/0469
Henry, J.
Delivered: 20/12/10

Grace Steele v Michael McIntyre et al
Claim No GDAHCV 2008/0251
Henry, J.
Delivered: 20/12/10

SAINT LUCIA
The Queen v Elian Phillip
Criminal Cases Nos. SLUCRD 2008/1216 & 1217
Benjamin, J.
Delivered: 21/12/10

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLAND

Grand Pacific Holdings Ltd v Pacific China Holdings Ltd
Claim No. BVIHCV 2009/389
Bannister, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 03/12/10

Royal Westminster Investments SA et al v Nilon Ltd et al
Claim No. BVIHCV 2009/389
Bannister, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 21/12/10

Cliff Williams et al v The Moorings Ltd
Claim No. BVIHCV 2009/0083
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 16/12/10

Loretta Frett v Attorney General
Claim No. BVIHCV 2007/0137
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 20/12/10

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA

Burton Riviere v Judith Durand
HCVAP 2006/013
Alleyne, C. J. [Ag.]
Delivered: 10/11/10

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Damian Hodge v The Queen
HCRAP 2009/001
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 10/11/10

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANGUILLA
Ashtrom Anguilla Ltd v Flag Luxury Properties (Anguilla) LLC et al
Claim No AXAHCV 0091/2009
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 30/11/10

Calefaccion Y Ventilacion SA DE C V v Flag Luxury Properties (Anguilla) LLC
Claim No. AXAHCV 0001/2010
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 30/11/10

Credit Suisse AG (Cayman Islands Branch) v Anguilla Masonry Products Co Ltd et al
Claim No. AXAHCV 0046/2010
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 30/11/10

ANTIGUA
The Liquidators of Eurofed Bank Ltd v The Supervisory Authority
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0298
Michel, J.
Delivered: 26/11/10

James N George et al v Eldica Benjamin
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0271
Thomas, J.
Delivered: 29/11/10

Everton Cornelius v Allan Stevens et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2006/0234
Thomas, J.
Delivered: 29/11/10

Myrtle Looby v Dorothy Gittens
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0388
Thomas, J.
Delivered: 29/11/10

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
David Robin et al v Ulysses Auguiste et al
DOMHCV 2003/0141
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 25/11/10

Edison James v Speaker of House et al and Hector John v Speaker of House et al
DOMHCV 2010/0199, DOMHCV 2010/0200
Stephenson-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 22/11/10

The State v Deveril Benjamin
Case No 24 of 2010
Stephen-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 25/11/10

Kironie Sandy v The State
Claim No DOMHCV 2010/0312
Stephen-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 26/11/10

GRENADA

Maria Harford v Gabriel Harford
Claim No. GDAHMT 1999/0112
Henry, J.
Delivered: 30/11/10

Patrick Thomas et al v Thomas Real Estate Co Ltd et al and Crochu Beach Resorts Ltd et al
Claim Nos. GDAHCV 2001/0652, 2001/0653
Henry, J.
Delivered: 30/11/10

Ann Robertson v AG
DOMHCV 2004/0265
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 11/11/10

Liberty Club Ltd v Beacon Insurance Co Ltd
Claim No. GDAHCV 2005/0409
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 22/11/10

Christopher Lord v Geraldine Pitt-Samuel
Claim No. GDAHCV 2006/0465
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 29/11/10

Catherine Maria St. Bernard v Olive Virginia McEwen
Claim No. GDAHCV 2008/0515
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 29/11/10

ST KITTS & NEVIS
Lindsay Fitz-Patrick Grant  v Glen Fitzroy Phillip et al
Claim No. SKBHCV 2010/00
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 04/11/10

Santos Perez et al v Minister of Nat. Security and Immigration et al
Claim No. NEVHCV 2010/0042
Leigertwood-Octave, J.
Delivered: 09/11/10

Leonne Skeete v Kenneth Skeete
Claim No. NEVHMT 2007/0022
Leigertwood-Octave, J.
Delivered: 11/11/10

Shuric Merchant v Tameika Williams
Claim No. NEVHCV 2009/0085
Leigertwood-Octave, J.
Delivered: 11/11/10

 

SAINT LUCIA
Prudence Robinson v Sagicor General Insurance Inc.
SLUHCV 2008/736
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 18/11/10

Samantha Anthony v Gregory Edward
SLUHCV 2008/0656
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 19/11/10

Patricia Edmund v Sr. Magistrate Floreta Nicholas
SLUHCV 2009/483
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 24/11/10

Robert Antoine v Johnston International Ltd
SLUHCV 2008/0975
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 30/11/10

Joanne Rowan et al v Bryan Stephen
Complaint No. 5 of 2006
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 17/11/10

Barbara Mc Quilkin et al v Aloysius Polius
Claim No. SLUHCV 2007/0119
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 25/11/10

1st National Bank St Lucia Ltd v Universal Fishing and Trading Co Ltd et al
Claim No. SLUHCV 2007/0998
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 30/11/10

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS

Vance Lewis v Joyce Lewis
Claim No. BVIHMT 2008/0062
Hariprashad-Charles, J.

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Jacqui Quinn-Leandro v Dean Jonas … election petitions
HCVAP 2010/018, 2010/019, 2010/020
Rawlins, C.J.
Delivered: 27/10/10

Janice Reynolds-Greene v Community First Cooperative Credit Union
HCVAP 2008/027
Edwards, J. A.
Delivered: 25/10/10

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Maureen Peters v The Queen
HCRAP 2009/005
Baptiste, J.A.
Delivered: 01/10/10

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Mathurin Jurgensen v Public Utilities Authority
Claim No ANUHCV 2004/0528
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 14/10/10

Jack Scott et al v Wayne Robinson et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0056
Gonsalves, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 21/10/10

Andrea Stoelker et al v Bank of Antigua
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0197
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

The Supervisory Authority v The Liquidators of Eurofed Bank
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0298
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

C O Williams Construction (Antigua) Ltd v Jennings Building Production Ltd
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0484
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

Geotech Co Ltd v Akindele Looby
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0578
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

Akindele Looby et al v Dorothy Gittens et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0357
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

Antigua Real Estates Ltd v Rupert Kenlock
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0041
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

The Public Utilities Authority v Lester Bryant Bird et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0353
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

Geo w Bennett, Bryson & Co Ltd et al v Akindele Looby
Claim No ANUHCV 2007/0722
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

The Public Utilities Authority v Shoppers Pharmacy et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0605
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

Rupert Anthony v Patrice Browne et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0362
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

Aziz Hadeed v Phillip Abbot
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0058
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

Clive Oliveira v Attorney Geneal
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0608
Harris, J.
Delivered: 12/10/10

Annette Tuitt v ABI Bank Ltd
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0583
Michel, J.
Delivered: 20/10/10

Anita Tobitt et al v Stanford Frederick
Claim No ANUHCV 2006/0026
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 13/10/10

Akeem Murraine v Antigua and Barbuda Hospitals Board
Claim No ANUHCV 2008/0233
Michel, J.
Delivered: 14/10/10

Herman Esprit v Glenda Esprit
Claim No ANUHCV 2009/0616
Michel, J.
Delivered: 28/10/10

ANGUILLA
Audrey Smith v Hilton Fleming
Claim No AXAHCV 019/1997
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 14/10/10

Linda Tamn v The Fountain Beach and Tennis Club Ltd
Claim No AXAHCV 007/2009
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 28/10/10

Lystra Ewen v Charles Sylvester Liddie
Claim No AXAHCV 0044/2007
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 30/10/10

Sylvanie Connor et al v Ileen Hodge-Richardson
Claim No AXAHCV 0043/2008
Blenman, J.
Delivered: 30/10/10

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Lucy Paul v Emmanuel Joseph
Claim No DOMHCV 0172 of 2003
Stephenson-Brooks, J.
Delivered: 01/10/10

GRENADA
Dexter Smith v Attorney General et al
Claim No GDAHCV 2008/0328
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 07/10/10

Ronald Lessey v Garth Gellineau
Claim No GDAHCV 2007/0413
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 07/10/10

Bradford Noel v First Caribbean International Bank (Barbados) Ltd
Claim No. GDAHCV 2004/0109
Henry, J.
Delivered: 18/10/10

First Caribbean International Bank (Barbados) Ltd v Bradford Noel
Claim No. GDAHCV 2004/0109
Henry, J.
Delivered: 18/10/10

Republic Bank (Grenada) Ltd v Alana Brathwaite et al
Claim Nos. GDAHCV 2007/0345, 2007/0417
Price-Findlay, J.
Delivered: 07/10/10

ST KITTS & NEVIS
Cedric Liburd v Eugene Hamilton et al
Claim No. SKBHCV2010/0020
Hariprashad-Charles, J.
Delivered: 13/10/10

SAINT LUCIA
Simone Jean Popo v John Popo et al and Victor Hippolyte et al v Simone Jean Popo
SLUHCV 2007/502, 2008/012
Georges, J.
Delivered: 14/10/10

Martin Devaux v Theresa Goddard et al
SLUHCV 2008/0405
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 07/10/10

Patrick Morille v Hermia Morille
Claim No SLUHCV 2010/0285
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 27/10/10

1st National Bank of St Lucia Ltd v Universal Fishing and Trading Co Ltd
Claim No SLUHCV 2007/0998
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 29/10/10

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES

Elroy Arthur v T Michael Findlay
High Court Civil Claim No. 36 of 2009
Joseph, J.
Delivered: 04/10/10

Michelle Jones v The Saint Vincent and the Grenadines Port Authority
High Court Civil Claim No. 171 of 2009
Joseph, J.
Delivered: 13/10/10

Emmanual Johnson Chijioke v The Commissioner of Police et al and  Benjamin Fiifi Danquah v The Commissioner of Police et al
High Court Civil Claim Nos. 232 of 2010, 233 of 2010
Joseph, J.
Delivered: 21/10/10

Erlene Richardson v Helenor Williams et al
Claim No. SVGHCV 2009/044
Lanns, M.
Delivered: 18/10/10

Dr Ralph Gonsalves v Junior Bacchus et al
Claim No. SVGHCV 2009/0221
Mathurin, M.
Delivered: 06/10/10

Angela Hinkson v Gibson Construction Ltd
High Court Civil Claim No. 149 of 2007
Thom, J.
Delivered: 05/10/10

Burton Williams v Elvineal Richards et al and Alexis Ollivierre v Andre Browne
High Court Civil Claim No. 133 of 2008
Thom, J.
Delivered: 13/10/10

Jomo Thomas v The Comptroller of Customs et al
High Court Civil Claim No. 331 of 2008
Thom, J.
Delivered: 20/10/10

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

GRENADA

Jude Jack v Attorney General et al
CLAIM NO. GDAHCV 2006/0351
Henry, J.
Delivered: 15/09/10

Reynold Benjamin et al v Blue Lagoon Real Estate Corporation
CLAIM NO. GDAHCV2004/0235
Henry, J.
Delivered: 15/09/10

Capital Bank International Ltd v Keith Mitchell et al
CLAIM NO. GDAHCV2008/0109
Henry, J.
Delivered: 23/09/10

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

SAINT LUCIA

The Queen v Alexander Bonnet
CLAIM NO. SLUCRD 2008/0499
Benjamin, J
Delivered: 27/07/10