JUDGMENTS DELIVERED DURING THE MONTH OF AUGUST 2010

COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS

ANGUILLA
Hotel de Health (Caribbean) Inc v James Webster et al
HCVAP 2008/004
Gordon, J.A. [Ag]
Delivered: 18/08/10

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Gaston Browne v AG Antigua and Barbuda et al
HCVAP 2009/024
George-Creque, J.A.
Delivered: 13/08/10

GRENADA
SGL Holdings v Aiham Shammas
HCVAP 2010/002
George-Creque, J.A.
Delivered: 13/08/10

SAINT VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Chatham Bay Club v Judith Jones-Morgan
HCVAP 2007/021
George-Creque, J.A.
Delivered: 13/08/10

TERRITORY OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
Trade and Commerce Bank v Island Point Properties et al
HCVAP 2009/012
George-Creque, J.A.
Delivered: 13/08/10

HIGH COURT JUDGMENTS

ANTIGUA & BARBUDA
Claudy Brown v AG et al
Claim No ANUHCV 2010/0291
Michel, J.
Delivered: 09/08/10

COMMONWEALTH OF DOMINICA
Travis Desir v Paramount Printers et al
DOMHCV 2005/0219
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 17/08/10

Josephine Grayson v Joycelyn Seaman
DOMHCV 2009/0084
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 17/08/10

Claudia Henry v Albert Thomas
DOMHCV 2006/0009
Cottle, J.
Delivered: 20/08/10

John Henry Abraham v Kelver Darroux et al
DOMHCV 2010/0003, 0004, 0005, 0006, 0007
Thomas, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 25/08/10

SAINT LUCIA
Augustin Malaykhan v Prescilia Malaykhan
SLUHMT 2009/0106
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 03/08/10

Sherma Mathurin v Rain Forest Sky Rides Ltd
SLUHCV 2008/0551
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 03/08/10

Imran Jean v Attorney General et al
SLUHCV 2008/0790
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 12/08/10

Bertha Compton v Christiana Nathaniel et al
SLUHCV 2000/0031
Georges, J. [Ag]
Delivered: 20/08/10

Roland Brown v AG et al
Claim No SLUHCV 2009/0730
Wilkinson, J.
Delivered: 06/08/10

ST VINCENT & THE GRENADINES
Luthel Debique v Garfield Barker
High Court Civil Claim No. 337of 2007
Bruce-Lyle, J.
Delivered: 04/08/10

Michele Morthely v Adolphus Olivierre et al
High Court Civil Claim No. 334 of 2008
Bruce-Lyle, J.
Delivered: 06/08/10

Privy Council decisions originating from the OECS.

ANG: Anguilla | ANT: Antigua & Barbuda | DOM: Commonwealth of Dominicia | GRN: Grenada | MON: Montserrat | SKN: St. Kitts & Nevis | SLU: St. Lucia | SVG: St. Vincent & The Grenadines | TVI: Territory of the Virgin Islands |

• 09
• 08
• 07
• 06
• 05
• 04
• 03
• 02
• 01
• 00
• 99
• 98
• 97
• Pre 97

ANT - Philmore Jarvis v Shoppers Pharmacy
ANT - Alistair Greene v Half Moon Bay Hotel
ANG - John Gumbs v AG of Anguilla
DOM - Julius Corbette v National Bank of Dominica
SLU - Sylvinia Louisien v Joachim Jacob
SLU - National Insurance Corp v Winmark Ltd
SLU - Felicia George v Eagle Air Services Ltd
SLU - Felicia George et al v Eagle Air Services
SLU - Theresa Henry et al v Calixtus Henry
SVG - Daniel Trimmingham v The Queen
SKN - Evanson Mitcham v The Queen
TVI - Cukurova Finance International Ltd v Alfa Telecom Turkey Ltd

ANT - Elaine Knowles v George Knowles
ANT - Hilroy Humphreys v Attorney General (REASONS)
ANT - FBO 2000 (Antigua) Ltd v Vere Bird et al
DOM - Dominica Social Security Board v Nature Island Investment
SKN - Angela Inniss v Attorney General
SLU - Benoit Leriche v Leon Cherry
SLU - Horace Fraser v JLSC and AG (REASONS ON COSTS)
SLU - Horace Fraser v JLSC
SLU - Monica Plummer v Conway Bay
SLU - Benoit Lercihe v Francis Maurice
SVG - Treldon Connell v Claribelle Connell and Marcelle Findlay
TVI - DPP v Selena Varlack
TVI - David Hague et al v Nam Tai
TVI - ThomasTownsend et al v Persistence Holdings
TVI - DPP v William Penn

ANT - HMB Holdings Limited v Cabinet of Antigua & Barbuda
ANT - Lynne Abbott v Dane Abbott
GRN - Bernard Coard et al v Attorney General
GRN - Julia Lawrence v Attorney General
SLU - Noellina Maria Prospere v Frederick Prospere et al
SLU - Clendon Louis v Andrew Smith I
SLU - Francis Phillip & Kim John v The Queen
SVG - Ken Charles v The Queen
SVG - Richard Joachim et al v Attorney General et al
SVG - Randolph Toussaint v AG of Saint Vincent & The Grenadines
TVI - Citco Banking Corporation NV v Pusser's Ltd
TVI - Nathalie Creque v Cecil Penn

ANT - Joseph Horsford v Lester Bird et al
ANT - StanfordInternational Bank v Austin Lapps
ANT - Joseph Horsford v Lester Bird - Hope Costs
GRN - Edmund Gilbert v Queen
TVI - Ludwis Wheatley et al v Comm of Police
TVI - David Hague v Nam Tai et al

ANT - George ryan et al v Strickland Jarvis
DOM - Bally Sheng Balson v State
DOM - Leroy langford et al v State
MON - Blakes Estate Ltd v Govt of Montserrat
SKN - Noel Heath v Govt USA

GRN - Dipcon Engineering v George Bowen et al
GRN - George Worme et al Comm of Police
SKN - The Attorney General for St. Christopher & Nevis v Alexandre Rodionov
SKN - Attorney General v Alexandre Rodionov
TVI - Attorney General v Craig Hartwell
TVI - Errol Arthurton v Queen

ANT - Antigua Public Utilities v Malcolm Edwards
ANT - Eustace Potter v Port Services Ltd
SLU - Parry Husbands v Warefact Ltd
TVI - Franklyn Dailey v Harriet Dailey
TVI - Alexander Benedetto v Queen
TVI - Alexander Benedetto v Queen (2) LAST

ANG - Myron Goldfinger et al v Norman Luxemburg
DOM - John Charles v Yvette Barzey
GRN - Eric Jemmott v Comm of Police
GRN - Queen v Rennie Gilbert
SKN - Berthill Fox v Queen
SKN - Noel heath et al v Govt USA
SLU - Leonard Ogilvy v Minister of Legal Affairs
SLU - Geest plc v Monica Lansiquot
SLU - Queen v Peter Hughes

ANG - John Benjamin et al v Hon Minister of Information and Broadcasting
ANG - Confessor Valdez Franco v Queen
ANG - Observer Publications v Campbell Matthew et al
GRN - Andre Bennett et al v Queen
GRN - Jennifer Gairy v Attorney General
GRN - Michael Yearwood v Queen *
SKN - Berthill Fox v Queen
SVG - Newton Spence v Queen

ANT - John Baughman v Queen
ANT - HMB Holdings Limited v Cabinet of Antigua & Barbuda
ANT - Lynne Abbott v Dane Abbott
DOM - Cable and Wireless v Marpin Telecoms
GRN - Sharon Otway et al v Jean Gibbs
GRN - Julia Lawrence v Attorney General
SLU - Kenneth Polinere et al v Lucy Felicien
SLU - Francis Phillip & Kim John v The Queen
SLU - Clendon Louis v Andrew Smith I
SVG - Cardinal Williams v Queen
SVG - Everad Nicholls v Queen
SVG - Ken Charles v The Queen
SVG - Randolph Toussaint v AG of Saint Vincent & the Grenadines
SVG - Yambou Development v Sally Kauser
TVI - Geoffrey Cobham v Joseph Frett
TVI - Choithram Internationsl et al v Lalibai Thakurdas Pagarani et al
TVI - Nathalie Creque v Cecil Penn

SKN - Browne v The Queen
SKN - Greene Browne v Queen
SLU - Spiricor v Attorney General et al
SVG - Cardinal Williams v Queen

ANT - Attorney General of Antigua and Barbuda and Others v Cuthwin Lennard Lake
ANT - Elloy de Freitas v Permanent Secretary of Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries, Land and Housing et al
GRN - Electrotec Services Ltd v Issa Nicholas (Grenada) Ltd
SVG - Eversley Thompson v Queen
SVG - Cardinal Williams v Queen

ANT - Donald Halstead v Attorney General et al
ANT - Joseph Horsford v Bernard Jarvis
GRN - Electrotec Services Ltd v Issa Nicholas (Grenada) Ltd
SLU - Clarence Michel et al v Lennard Augier et al
SVG - Randolph B Russell et al v Attorney General for the State of St Vincent and the Grenadines et al

Judgments in 1996
ANT - Everette Byers v Queen
ANT - Margaret Berridge et al v Benjies Business Centre
SVG - Ena Lewis v Henry St Hillaire et al
TVI - Racoon Ltd v Harris Turnbull et al

Judgments in 1994
ANT - Noel Davis et al v Henry Charles et al
SKN - Alceo Zuliani et al v Vernon Veira
SVG - Maurice Robertson v Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce
SVG - Owens Bank Ltd v Etoile Commerciale SA

Judgments in 1993
SLU - John Goddard v National Development Corporation